A study does not account for an important confounder, but the data may allow reanalysis.

Would you recommend major revision, rejection, or ask the editor for specialist input?

What would make the difference for you?

#PeerReview #AcademicChatter #CriticalReview #ReviewerSkills #ReviewerTips

A good #peerreviewer does not need to have every answer.

If you identify an important issue that falls outside your expertise, explain the concern clearly and let the editor know what kind of specialist input may be needed.

#PeerReview #PeerReviewTips #AcademicSkills #PhdSky #ReviewerSkills

What kind of feedback after an editorial decision would help you improve most as a #peerreviewer?

❓Editor’s rationale
❓Anonymized co-reviewer comments
❓Feedback on your report
❓Final decision only

What would you actually want to receive?

#PeerReview #ReviewerCommunity #ReviewerSkills #AcademicSky