3/4
Next, check how the authors handled the missing data.
Was the approach explained and justified? Did they explore whether reasonable alternatives would produce different results?
@reviewerone.bsky.social
@reviewerone.bsky.social3/4
Next, check how the authors handled the missing data.
Was the approach explained and justified? Did they explore whether reasonable alternatives would produce different results?
@reviewerone.bsky.social3/4
Then group the secondary comments separately.
That makes it much easier for the author to see what needs serious attention and what would simply improve clarity.
@reviewerone.bsky.socialWhat do you think gets overlooked most often in #peerreview?
☑ Data availability
☑ Limitations
☑ Conflicts of interest
☑ Reporting guidelines
Vote, then tell us what you wish reviewers checked more consistently.
#AcademicX #PeerReviewers #ManuscriptReview #PeerReviewSkills #ReviewerOne