"Shadows of P'Jem" is another episode reliant on familiar plotting, but finds success in solid character work and important world building, big picture elements. Most impactful is the charting of the evolution of Archer and T'Pol's partnership and trust. Essential stuff.

Score: 3.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Sleeping Dogs" is fairly routine in its execution, but the character moments are uniformly successful. Very strong scenes and meaningful development for T'Pol, Hoshi and Archer significantly elevate the well-worn plotting. Not a classic by any means, but it's worthwhile.

Score: 2.5/5
#TrekRewatch5

How would you rank this recent batch of episodes watched for #TrekRewatch5?

🟢 "Unexpected"
🟢 "Terra Nova"
🟢 "The Andorian Incident"
🟢 "Breaking the Ice"
🟢 "Civilization"
🟢 "Fortunate Son"
🟢 "Cold Front"
🟢 "Silent Enemy"
🟢 "Dear Doctor"

"Dear Doctor" takes full advantage of #Enterprise's prequel concept, and finds a fresh approach to a prime directive sort of dilemma. I love the whimsical approach to its pacing, using a distinctive and memorable score to underline that tonal approach. Compelling drama.

Score: 5.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Silent Enemy" is a sturdily built action thriller with a less successful, oddly paired B-story. There's good character work throughout, but the imbalance of tones gives it a bit of an uneven feeling. The power of the A-story and killer production values carry the day.

Score: 3.5/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Cold Front" is a plot heavy, essential entry into #ENT's overarching story. The introduction of Daniels and establishment of the Temporal Cold War as a recurring thread give it a sense of dramatic urgency. It works very well when it leans into its mysterious qualities.

Score: 4.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Fortunate Son" explores some big picture ideas core and specific to #Enterprise, but largely skirts the most interesting opportunities along those lines. What is presented is a largely routine, and standard-issue story with mixed results from the central performances.

Score: 2.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Civilization" takes a classical approach conceptually and begins with great promise. However, the tone becomes less fun and more routine as it progresses. It's well designed, with outstanding sets, costumes and an evocative score. Well made but lacking emotional impact.

Score: 2.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Breaking the Ice" is a modest, reserved drama, taking a relaxed, almost day in the life approach, giving its character moments room to breathe. It's well balanced, offering the cast quality opportunities to shine. Far from the most memorable outing, but it's rock solid.

Score: 3.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"The Andorian Incident" overcomes the framework of a fairly basic hostage drama, with well executed plotting, major tone-setting twists, and dynamic character interplay. Jeffrey Combs' Shran is an all-timer #StarTrek guest character, bringing incredible energy to the mix.

Score: 4.5/5
#TrekRewatch5

Doubling back post #TrekRewatch5:

"Broken Bow" - 4.5 ↔️
"Fight or Flight" - 3.0 ⏬
"Strange New World" - 3.0 ↔️
"Unexpected" - 2.0 ⏫
"Terra Nova" - 2.0 ⏫

"Terra Nova" covers familiar ground, but it leans into prequel specifics in a way that provides just enough of a fresh flavor to mesh with the well-worn foundation. Strong guest performances and a uniquely evocative score are the highlights of this uneven, mixed bag.

Score: 2.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Unexpected" is quite successful in the early going with an immersive and ambitious approach to conveying a truly alien enviornment. When the story pivots into outright comedy and its (self awarely) absurd premise, things go awry with its obvious, and on the nose jokes.

Score: 2.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

How would you rank this recent batch of episodes watched for #TrekRewatch5?

🟣 "Q2"
🟣 "Author, Author"
🟣 "Friendship One"
🟣 "Natural Law"
🟣 "Homestead"
🟣 "Renaissance Man"
🟣 "Endgame"
🟢 "Broken Bow"
🟢 "Fight or Flight"
🟢 "Strange New World"

"Strange New World" opens with a wide-eyed optimism and prequel-specific approach to a fairly routine #StarTrek story structure. The bulk of the episode relies heavily on an effective psychological thriller overlay, which is deployed to target important character notes.

Score: 3.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Fight or Flight" is a fitting follow up to “Broken Bow”, putting a major focus on exploring Hoshi and Archer’s struggles to find their proverbial space legs in their respective roles. It effectively uses horror elements to drive home the prequel nature of the series.

Score: 3.0/5
#TrekRewatch5

"Broken Bow" reinvents the #StarTrek construct and represents the most meaningful break from the routine stylistically and tonally to this point of the franchise. It’s jam packed, but somehow manages to avoid feeling overloaded. Incredible production values for the time.

Score: 4.5/5
#TrekRewatch5

A few more generic #TrekRewatch5 updates:

✅ Rewatch Completion Percentage
✅ Season average scores ranked chart
✅ Current top 100 overall by series share
✅ Current top 200 overall by series share

Some generic #TrekRewatch5 updates following the wrap-up of #Voyager.

✅ Full readout of episode scores and season averages to date
✅ Score value distribution all shows combined to date
✅ Full point percentages series comparative view
✅ Total point percentages series comparative view

🧵 #StarTrek #VGR wrap-up readouts from #TrekRewatch5 appear within this thread.

Beginning here with my full series episode rankings for Star Trek: Voyager.

This rewatch ran from November 28, 2025-September 6, 2026. 172 episodes in 283 days.